Miami Marlins catcher Joe Mack (80) throws to first base. Sam Navarro-Imagn Images When assessing fantasy baseball rosters, the catcher position is often treated like a “set it and forget it” chore.
Many managers settle for a mediocre veteran who provides a stable but uninspiring .240 average and a handful of home runs, fearing the volatility of the waiver wire.
However, if you want to win your league, you cannot afford a black hole in your lineup.
Being aggressive with upgrades behind the plate is the “marginal gain” that separates champions from the middle of the pack.
The Marlins are doing just that, as they’ve made the decision to upgrade their own backstop situation and demote Agustín Ramírez to the minors. The 24-year-old’s .230 average and lack of power just weren’t enough to offset the defensive liabilities. Though Ramírez has flashed potential, his struggle to find consistency has opened the door for Joe Mack to take over the primary duties.
If you are looking for a spark, Mack is your primary target. A former first-round pick, Mack has spent the past year refining a profile that screams fantasy relevance.
His greatest asset is his raw power potential. He has the strength to turn on mid-90s fastballs and pull them into the seats, a rarity for a young backstop. Perhaps more importantly for those in OBP leagues, Mack has demonstrated elite on-base skills throughout his minor league tenure. He isn’t just a “swing for the fences” type, he possesses a keen eye and a willingness to draw walks — ensuring that even when the hits aren’t falling, he’s contributing to your peripheral stats.
Miami Marlins catcher Joe Mack (80) looks on. Sam Navarro-Imagn Images With Ramírez out of the picture, the playing time is Mack’s to lose.
Savvy managers shouldn’t stop there. While everyone else is fighting over Mack, you can also be looking one step ahead at the South Side of Chicago. Kyle Teel, the highly touted White Sox prospect, is expected to return from the injured list early next week.
Teel is the ultimate “glue guy” for a fantasy roster. He doesn’t just offer one specific skill, he provides a “little bit of everything” profile that is incredibly rare at the catcher position. He has enough pop to hit double-digit homers, but he separates himself with his athleticism.
Teel has the speed to swipe 5-10 bags a year, a massive advantage in a position usually occupied by plodding runners. Like Mack, Teel is a disciplined hitter who prioritizes on-base work, making him a safe floor player with a high ceiling.
The message is clear: Don’t settle for “good enough” at catcher. The Marlins and White Sox are handing the keys to their future stars, and you should do the same for your fantasy team.
Grab Joe Mack to reap the immediate rewards of his power, and stash Kyle Teel now before his activation creates a bidding war. In a long season, the manager who is proactive in the weakest positions ends up on top.
Howard Bender is the head of content at FantasyAlarm.com. Follow him on X @rotobuzzguy, catch him on the award-winning “Fantasy Alarm Radio Show” on SiriusXM Fantasy Sports Radio (Ch. 87) weekdays from 6-8 p.m. and dominate your leagues with the latest baseball news and advice from Fantasy Alarm.
