Make California Post a Preferred Source Mayor-elect Nithya Raman has pledged to reduce homelessness by half for the 2028 Olympic Games in LA, and bring everyone in tents and encampments indoors by the end of her first term.
It is preferable for politicos to under-promise and over-deliver. Raman has established a notable and ambitious goal, but Angelenos have heard it before.
Former mayors Antonio Villaraigosa, Eric Garcetti, and (soon-to-be-former mayor) Karen Bass made similar pledges to reduce the heartbreaking homelessness problem.
Villaraigosa (in 2006) and Garcetti (in 2013) each unveiled a 10-year plan to “end homelessness.” Ten years came and went.
Bass pledged to “end homelessness” by the end of her term. A pledge unfulfilled.
Mayor Bass championed the “Inside Safe” program, which sought to clear encampments and place homeless in motels at an estimated cost of $226/night. The city recently purchased and converted a Motel 6 in North Hills at a cost of $72 million, or $650,000 per unit.
Raman wants to end that program and use rental vouchers. Will that work? New construction financed through ballot proposition HHH is costing $600,000-825,000 per unit.
The problem has not been a lack of financial resources. LA city and county have combined to spend well over $1 billion with marginal impact. The last city budget allocated $417 million to homeless services this year.
Can Raman deliver on her goal for the Olympics? Yes, with a caveat: If it is on a temporary basis.
Gov. Gavin Newsom authorized a cleanup of downtown San Francisco prior to the 2023 Asian-Pacific Economic Cooperation summit that welcomed Chinese President Xi Jinping.
The streets were cleaned, but the problem was masked, as critics complained that San Francisco had merely moved the unhoused from their downtown encampments to locations elsewhere in the city. Newsom publicly acknowledged that the transformation was only done due to the arrival of “fancy leaders coming to town.”
Raman could follow the Newsom playbook, and move homeless away from Olympics venues, housing villages, and hotels on a temporary basis. How much would that cost? Would the public accept that “shell game” cleanup?
During the campaign for mayor, Raman criticized the ’28 Olympics, especially how the public had “no say in any of it.” She was one of two City Council members to vote against the city contract that allows the private Olympic committee, LA28, to drag the city into debt. Raman called the agreement a “blank check,” and many agree.
The 1984 Olympics established the modern template — I was there. I was a top aide to two LA City Council members, Zev Yaroslavsky and Bob Ronka, and assisted in the drafting of the LA City Charter amendment that guaranteed the city would avoid financial liability for the ’84 Olympics.
The question is whether Raman can actually deliver on a 50% reduction in homelessness in less than two years.
The LA form of government reduces any mayor’s authority. The 15-member City Council enacts ordinances with eight votes, and can override a mayor’s veto with 10 votes. Raman will have a honeymoon period — a brief honeymoon. None of the council members endorsed her candidacy, and while four “Democratic Socialists” are politically and philosophically aligned with her, the knives will be out if she stumbles.
The mayor-elect has an ally in LA County Supervisor Lindsay Horvath, who endorsed her. Horvath seeks to be the county’s first CEO and would love to have a popular mayor endorse her in 2028. The city controller and city attorney are both DSA supporters, but it is the council that holds the legislative authority.
A handful of council members envision themselves as more capable mayors than Raman and the behind-the-scenes positioning to confront her is imminent.
The ’84 Games generated a $230 million surplus, and the spirit of LA was revitalized. We confronted and met the financial problem with the charter amendment. Homelessness was not an issue.
Raman faces many skeptics. She will need a supportive council and a patient electorate, but the clock is ticking, with only 20 months until the July 2028 opening ceremonies.
Wayne Avrashow is an attorney who served on two LA government commissions.