Make New York Post a Preferred Source Most Americans think they’re on the nice list this year, but their spending may tell a different story, according to new research.
A survey of 2,000 U.S. adults split evenly by generation who celebrate the winter holidays revealed that while 70% believe they’d be on Santa’s nice list, a majority (79%) admit to partaking in many financially naughty habits.
This year, those polled spent money they intended to save (29%), made a purchase just because it was on sale (28%), and paid more for something simply because they wanted it sooner (20%).
Still, 16% of respondents own the fact that they’d be on the naughty side. Gen X is most likely to admit they consider themselves naughty (20%), followed by millennials (18%), but results revealed they actually aren’t the biggest offenders.
This year, Gen Z is most likely to think they’re on the nice list (79%), but they’re also more likely than any other generation to engage in some naughty behaviors (94%).
One quarter of Gen Z also admit to making impulsive purchases over $100 and waiting so long to do something that it ended up costing even more money (both 26%), while nearly one in five (19%) bought something because they were jealous of what somebody else had.
And though there’s still time to turn things around, many will continue with their naughty behaviors into the holiday season, with Gen Z once again leading the pack (85%).
Gen Z plans to regift something and then try to pass it off as new (21%) and lie about how much they spent on something or someone (17%).
Conducted by Talker Research on behalf of Chime (https://www.chime.com/), the survey also explored Americans’ nicer side and found that most of those polled are actually a mix of sugar and spice.
In 2026, many of those polled waited patiently for something they really wanted to go on sale instead of buying at retail price (34%), focused their spending on experiences rather than material objects (30%), and “paid it forward” to someone else, such as paying for the next car’s order at the drive-thru or covering a stranger’s check (27%).
This holiday season, many nice-listers have continued their trend by walking away from something that wasn’t worth the price (34%) or choosing not to buy something because they knew they’d regret it later (27%) — nearly a third (32%) even realized spending more doesn’t actually make the holiday better.
They say you get what you give, and they may be right. Many of those polled have been on the receiving end of good karma in 2026 with rising credit scores (31%), being given an unexpected monetary gift (27%), or someone else paying for their check (27%).
And being rewarded by the universe isn’t the only benefit respondents are receiving; 73% agree that getting rewarded for their holiday spending would make it feel even more worthwhile.
This year, two-thirds plan to use rewards, cashback, or both to pay for holiday purchases.In total, those who plan to cash in their rewards expect to use an average of nearly $250 ($247.30), and those who will use their cash back are looking at an average of $230 ($231.20).
“Most people aren’t exclusively naughty or nice with their money. They’re a little bit of both, and the holidays tend to bring that out,” said Janelle Sallenave, Chime’s Chief Spending Officer. “The goal isn’t to feel guilty about spending, but to be intentional about where your money goes and look for opportunities, like rewards and cash back, to get more out of the purchases you’re already making.”
According to the results, Americans consider some expenses always worth the cost, including food or the ingredients for holiday meals and baking (36%), gifts (34%), traveling to visit family (28%), and holiday decor (25%).
But many would rather skip costs like matching outfits (25%), going to see “Santa” (22%), and hosting expenses (16%).
With so many important items on the tab, this may be why a majority of respondents (59%) say that earning rewards and cash back during the holiday season is more important than during the rest of the year.
“Results found that the top three spends that felt most worthwhile this year weren’t shortcuts or luxurious; they were simply bringing joy to themselves (38%) or a loved one (32%) or reducing stress (32%), underscoring a need to embrace life’s little pleasures,” said Sallenave.
TOP “NICE” FINANCIAL BEHAVIORS IN 2026
TOP “NAUGHTY” FINANCIAL BEHAVIORS IN 2026
Talker Research surveyed 2,000 U.S. adults split evenly by generation (500 Gen Z, 500 millennials, 500 Gen X, and 500 baby boomers) who celebrate the winter holidays and who have access to the internet; the survey was commissioned by Chime and administered and conducted online by Talker Research between Oct. 23 and Nov. 2, 2026.