Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Privacy-First Edition
Back to NNN
World

So is John Mulaney the best ‘Saturday Night Live’ host of all time?

Make Decider a Preferred Source Photo: SNL/NBC Where to Stream: Saturday Night Live Powered by Reelgood More On: John Mulaney Is ‘Saturday Night Live’ New Tonight? Here Are The Next Three Hosts For ‘SNL’ Season 52 Why Was John Mulaney Censored At the Emmys? ‘SNL’ Alums Pete Davidson And John Mulaney Admit They Lied To Bombing Hosts About Bad Monologues: “You Crushed It” Stream It Or Skip It: ‘Josh Johnson: Symphony’ On HBO Max, The Comedian Who’s Making A Lot Of Noise (Complimentary) John Mulaney hosted Saturday Night Live for the seventh time over the weekend, and pretty much everyone agrees that it was the best episode of the season’s six installments so far. Actually, that seems too minor a distinction for such an unusually top-to-bottom strong outing; the real question is whether this was the best episode of the past two or three seasons – or, moreover, where this puts Mulaney on the list of the show’s all-time best hosts.

In terms of sheer numbers, Mulaney has racked up a crazy run. Five is considered the bar for an established frequent host, per the show’s joke-turned-actual “five-timers’ club.” Hosting seven times puts Mulaney in the top ten most-frequent hosts ever; other seven-timers include Scarlett Johansson and Christopher Walken, and he’s in no danger of Chevy Chase hosting again before Mulaney can rack up the nine episodes needed to pass him. What’s wilder is that of all the hosts who have done it five times or more, Mulaney had the most recent start by far; he first hosted in 2018 and has more or less done it annually since then, with seven of the past nine seasons including a Mulaney episode.

Technically, though, that just covers quantity, and Mulaney does have an edge given that he worked at SNL as a writer (with a couple of little-talked-about Weekend Update appearances) before finding greater fame as a stand-up comedian. Like Johansson, who is married to longtime staffer Colin Jost, his connections to the show will keep him coming back for the foreseeable future. So what about quality?

As it happens, Mulaney’s biggest competition are the other hosts who have ascended into the upper echelons of multiple hosting gigs. After all, you don’t get to 16 (Steve Martin) or 13 (John Goodman) or even 10 (Tom Hanks) episodes without being really damn good at it, to say nothing of what’s needed to hold the record without even counting a seasons-long stint as a part-time cast member impersonating Donald Trump, as 17-timer Alec Baldwin did. The extended relationship with the show is what helps most of those competitors; Mulaney, with all of his episodes happening in the past years, can’t claim era-crossing interactions with the original cast (like Martin), the Dana Carvey/Mike Myers years (like Martin and Baldwin), or the Will Ferrell era (like Goodman in particular, who hosted almost every season of the 1990s and made several guest appearances playing Linda Tripp during the Monica Lewinsky scandal). He also doesn’t have a signature recurring character as notable as those boasted by multiple hosts like Walken, Jonah Hill, or Melissa McCarthy.

Where Mulaney excels, as he did last weekend, is putting his own imprint on each episode. Martin is so closely identified with those early years of the show, and fit into the cast so seamlessly, that some forget that he wasn’t just a regular. Similarly, Tina Fey is an all-time great host, but because she spent years as head writer, her episodes don’t feel so much like she’s steering the show so much as it’s operating smoothly without a host. Mulaney was never in charge at the show, which gives him a stronger voice when the spotlight is reoriented on him. The sketches might work well enough with other hosts plugged into them, but the slight remove of Mulaney’s performance style combined with his comic’s ability to time out his punchlines makes him both the subject of the scene and a performer uniquely qualified to knock it home. That’s especially clear in his series of sketches about New York oddities, dramatized as spoofs of classic Broadway musicals – especially the original version, “Diner Lobster,” where a customer’s insistence on ordering the ubiquitous but ill-advised lobster on a diner menu turns into an elaborate parody of Les Miserables.

Even beyond that fan favorite, Mulaney’s episodes have yielded an unusual number of classics. This week’s buzziest sketch was the ad for a home-health aide just called “Sister,” pinpointing the gender inequality at the heart of so much eldercare with sharp and cathartic accuracy. Other highlights from past episodes include “What’s That Name,” a game-show trap revealing the capriciousness of our social connections; “Cha Cha Slide,” a more cheerfully whimsical bit where Mulaney’s seemingly white-bread character reveals his casually surprising affinity for Black culture; and a Sound of Music spoof.

That doesn’t mean every sketch in every episode is a bona fide home run (or that we should assume Mulaney is coming to each episode with an armload of sketches pre-written, though he has spoken about re-using rejected ideas from his hosting perch). If there’s a weakness with his seven episodes, it’s that between a longer monologue and his fidelity to those musical sketches he does every time – brilliant in “Diner Lobster,” hit-or-miss since – there often isn’t time for a full dozen or so segments, especially if there’s also an elaborate pretape in the offing. Mulaney also makes the show enough his own that he’s had several host-specific recurring sketches that aren’t run into the ground, but take up valuable real estate. In his sixth time back in 2024, for example, there was only time for him to feature in three live sketches, and two were signature recurring bits (the New York musical installment and an election-themed version of What’s That Name?).

A couple more cases for Mulaney, though: One is his monologue, which has the unfair but distinct advantage of getting to be a stand-up mini-set, and given that it’s his day job, it tends to be pretty damn good. The other is more mysterious: Does he always insist on having a particularly strong musical guest? Usually the host doesn’t have a say – but if anyone could push for that, it’s probably a distinguished alumnus with a pre-existing Lorne Michaels relationship. It seems pretty likely that Mulaney helped get David Byrne on the show for his third episode. But he’s also had The Strokes, Jack White, LCD Soundsystem, Chappell Roan, and Phoebe Bridgers – a certain kind of 21st-century alt royalty. If the usual SNL episode works out to somewhere in the C+/B- range, Mulaney consistently hits a B+ or higher.

All told, Martin and Hanks – the former one of the Wild and Crazy Guys; the latter David S. Pumpkins might maintain a small lead on Mulaney… for now. But neither of them host full episodes all that regularly anymore. Though Mulaney is in the upcoming movie Madden, he’s more of a novelty character actor than a big movie or TV star. In SNL‘s goodnights on Saturday, he said the past week had been his best in a long time, so it seems likely that he’ll keep dropping by every season or two. By the time he reaches double digits sometime in the early 2030s, he’ll probably be the reigning champion.

Peacock currently offers two subscription types: Premium with ads and Premium Plus ad-free. Peacock Premium costs $12.99/month, while Premium Plus costs $19.99/month.

You can save a bit by subscribing to one of Peacock’s annual plans, which give you 12 months for the price of 10. These cost either $129.99 with ads or $199.99 without ads.

Peacock Premium Plus is also available to subscribe to via Prime Video with a seven-day free trial that you can’t get by subscribing directly on Peacock.

Read original at New York Post

The Perspectives

0 verified voices · Three viewpoints · Real discourse

Left
0
Be the first to share a left perspective
Center
0
Be the first to share a center perspective
Right
0
Be the first to share a right perspective

Related Stories