Monday, November 16, 2026
Privacy-First Edition
Back to NNN
Politics

Good intentions can’t stop a riot, Mayor Mamdani

Make New York Post a Preferred Source NYPD officers chasing down an alleged terrorist after a homemade bomb was thrown at a protest outside of Gracie Mansion in Manhattan on March 7, 2026. Photo by CHARLY TRIBALLEAU / AFP via Getty Images When terrorists brought bombs to a demonstration near Gracie Mansion in March, NYPD Sgt. Luis Navarro ran toward a lit explosive device. Chief Aaron Edwards pursued and helped apprehend a suspect. Their courage helped stop an alleged ISIS-inspired attack from becoming a mass-casualty catastrophe.

They understood something Mayor Mamdani apparently still refuses to accept: A protest can become a terrorist crime scene in seconds.

Now the mayor is celebrating his decision to dismantle the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group as a campaign promise fulfilled.

New Yorkers should be asking whether the people entrusted with protecting them are being given a stronger defense or a dangerous political experiment.

As president of the Sergeants Benevolent Association, I know who will confront the consequences when that experiment meets reality: our sergeants, our police officers and the innocent people standing behind them.

The mayor’s plan creates an unarmed civilian division focused on dialogue and de-escalation, supported by a police dialogue team.

Counterterrorism duties will move elsewhere within the NYPD, while a new Patrol Support Division assumes crowd management responsibilities.

The administration insists these changes will preserve public safety.

Those assurances deserve scrutiny, particularly when the mayor’s central selling point is that he has delivered a political victory over a specialized police unit.

Dialogue has a place. Our members practice de-escalation every day. Peaceful demonstrators deserve protection, respect and the freedom to express themselves without unnecessary interference.

But an individual arriving with explosives, a weapon or a determination to assault police is not looking for a productive conversation.

Whether the mayor sends social workers or other civilian personnel, good intentions cannot provide arrest powers, tactical training or the ability to stop an armed attacker. Putting unarmed employees in that position also raises questions about their own safety.

Gracie Mansion operates under the comforting assumption that terrorism and protest response can always be neatly separated. The danger emerged within a demonstration.

The officers confronting it did not have the luxury of waiting for City Hall to decide which organizational box applied.

The mayor owes New Yorkers concrete answers. How quickly will trained officers reach a civilian team confronting violence?

What personnel and equipment will be immediately available?

Who decides when dialogue ends and intervention begins?

Reassigning responsibilities on an organizational chart does not answer those questions.

There is another danger: deterrence. Violent agitators watch what government does. My concern is that dismantling the SRG, while advertising a softer approach, will encourage people intent on violence to infiltrate otherwise peaceful protests because they expect less immediate resistance.

That threatens demonstrators as surely as it threatens police. Someone exercising constitutional rights should never become cover for someone carrying a bomb, attacking a bystander or hurling a weapon at an officer.

Accountability matters. Allegations of misconduct must be investigated, and officers must follow the law. But addressing misconduct requires effective supervision, training and discipline. It does not require treating specialized police readiness as an embarrassment.

Before this overhaul takes effect, City Hall should demonstrate that its replacement can handle simultaneous emergencies, sudden violence and the nightmare scenario already attempted outside the mayor’s residence.

New Yorkers deserve proof of readiness before the emergency, not explanations afterward. Our members should never have to compensate for political miscalculations with their lives. Neither should the public.

How many lives need to be lost to prove this experiment is flawed?

The answer should be none. The mayor should heed the lesson of Gracie Mansion: When violence erupts, the people who save lives are the ones trained, equipped and empowered to stop it immediately.

Vincent Vallelong is president of the NYPD Sergeants Benevolent Association.

Read original at New York Post

The Perspectives

0 verified voices · Three viewpoints · Real discourse

Left
0
Be the first to share a left perspective
Center
0
Be the first to share a center perspective
Right
0
Be the first to share a right perspective

Related Stories