Monday, November 16, 2026
Privacy-First Edition
Back to NNN
Entertainment

Are headphones robbing us of the silence required to actually think?

Make New York Post a Preferred Source Without fully realizing it, I slowly did away with silence in my life.

Headphones are as essential as house keys when I leave my place. They’re constant entertainment as I go about my errands and an adequate “don’t talk to me” signal on the subway. When I write or am tidying up, I almost always have ambient music playing. There are times when my boyfriend and I are each listening to a podcast — sometimes even the same one — in different corners of our tiny apartment. Every single moment of my life was filled with sound.

Until I lost my headphones earlier this month and was forced to start listening to my own thoughts.

It made me wonder: has the ease of wireless earbuds, streaming platforms, and the podcast industry colonized our minds and robbed us of the silent space that our own thoughts once occupied?

It’s common knowledge that short-form video content is wreaking havoc on our attention spans, but what if the stuff we think of as enrichment — music in the background, or even a stimulating conversation on a podcast — is also drawing on our cognitive reserves?

The scale of the potential problem is enormous. The majority of Americans — 170 million of them — own Bluetooth-enabled wireless headphones, and the typical American is now consuming four hours of audio content per day.

“If you’re cramming all this stuff into your brain all the time, then you don’t have time for [new thoughts] to happen,” Earl Miller, a professor of neuroscience at MIT, told me. “Instead of letting your mind go down the garden path to these new places, that’s going to blunt your creativity. You’re not going to be as creative.”

Miller studies cognition and attention, with a particular interest in multitasking — which seems more relevant than ever. The amount of time Americans spend listening to podcasts increased by 355% in just the past decade alone, per Edison Research, and the majority of listeners (68%) say they multitask almost all or most of the time they have one on.

“We’re very simple-minded creatures,” Miller said. “When we think we’re multitasking, what we’re actually doing is task switching. We’re switching our mind back and forth, like we’re juggling.”

His research has identified “switch costs” from all the toggling: “Every time the brain switches, it takes time. Your brain’s got to reconfigure.”

He also has a warning for podcast junkies who don’t think the conversations distract them as they work: his research found that confidence in one’s ability to multitask is actually inversely correlated with ability — meaning those who think they’re best at it are actually worse at task switching than people who think they’re bad at it.

According to Miller, we’re encountering a profound mismatch between our modern world and our evolutionary hardware. We crave content and constant stimulation, he says, because our brains were made to extract whatever they can from a rather low-information environment.

“Our brains evolved in an environment where there wasn’t a lot of information out there,” he said. “Any information might be really important, like a rustling in the bushes might be a tiger about to leap out. So your brain evolved to crave new information. But now … there’s too much information and your brain can’t turn it off.”

This is increasingly the case, as technology progresses. While one once had to tether oneself to a physical radio or a record player to consume auditory content, today any music or podcast imaginable is available with just a few taps and a Bluetooth connection to your cordless headphones. Researchers still haven’t caught up with the potential consequences.

“This is a pressing question, and we haven’t adequately investigated it,” Jonathan Schooler, professor of psychological and brain sciences at UC Santa Barbara, told The Post. “We need more research on this.”

Schooler studies mind-wandering — when one’s thoughts involuntarily drift away from the here and now — and its relationship to creativity. In a 2019 study, he found that idle mental time is critical for idea generation; among professional writers and physicists, a fifth of their most significant ideas in a day came from moments of spontaneous mind-wandering.

“Their creative ideas [occurred] when they were not actively pursuing the problem and when they were not at work,” he explained. “It seems quite plausible that if they’d had AirPods on and were listening to some other content, that might have interfered with this sort of natural mind-wandering that led to these ideas.”

Schooler expressed concern that “disrupting — not providing opportunity for — productive mind-wandering could lead to the failure to have ideas that we might otherwise have.”

One researcher looking for answers is John Everett Marsh of the University of Lancashire, a cognitive psychology researcher interested in how sound affects thinking and attention. His findings on headphones are mixed.

On the positive, they “allow us to maintain some control over our auditory environment,” like drowning out background chatter, and “create something of a personal bubble.”

But he’s identified a paradox: “on the one hand, headphones might protect us from unwanted external distractions, but, on the other hand, we sometimes fill them with distracting material of our own choosing.”

His recent research has also challenged the assumption that listening to music while working can stimulate creativity. He found study participants were worse at solving creative verbal problems while music was playing, with or without lyrics.

Marsh argued that “silence isn’t essential for creativity,” but he’s still concerned that an attention economy setting its sights on our ears could be problematic: “If we’re continually filling otherwise quiet moments with other people’s conversations, stories and ideas, might we be giving ourselves fewer opportunities to generate and explore our own?”

Schooler raised perhaps the most profound question of all — whether it’s not that we’re merely distracted by the constant stimulation of podcasts and influencers and music and streaming, but if our appreciation for the beauty of silence has faded. Perhaps, he says, simply being alone with our thoughts is something of a lost art.

“There’s a lack of tolerance for idle moments,” he worried. “It seems this taste for reverie — this taste for being left to your own devices — has been lost.”

Read original at New York Post

The Perspectives

0 verified voices · Three viewpoints · Real discourse

Left
0
Be the first to share a left perspective
Center
0
Be the first to share a center perspective
Right
0
Be the first to share a right perspective

Related Stories