Monday, November 16, 2026
Privacy-First Edition
Back to NNN
Sports

‘So much emotions’ after NY high school football team had undefeated season ripped away by off-field ruling

Make New York Post a Preferred Source Middletown High School’s football team has withdrawn a petition to overturn a decision that forced them to forfeit a Section 9 Class AA semifinal win, thus ending their season. Middletown had to forfeit their win over Valley Central due to an ineligible player.

Initial appeals failed to overturn the forfeiture before Middletown superintendent Amy Creeden sought court intervention. After learning that the judge would rule against the district, they ended their petition campaign.

“It sucks. It hurts,” Middletown quarterback Jo Jo Royal said. “There’s so much emotions going on inside my head. I feel so bad for the seniors. I got my hopes up when I told myself not to. And now it just feels like heartbreak all over again.”

The ineligibility issue stemmed from when coaches of Newburgh Free Academy, who Middletown was slated to face in the Section 9 AA Championship, watched semifinal game film and spotted a Middletown player they hadn’t seen previously, which they reported to Valley Central.

Valley Central’s athletic director then reported it to Section 9 for review.

That player was not listed on Middletown’s roster for three regular season games, which is required by Section 9, so Middletown was forced to forfeit, a result the district called “arbitrary and capricious.”

They claimed the violation was due to a misunderstanding with an adult and was not the fault of the player, who the district said was exclusively a kickoff specialist and only participated in eight kickoffs.

Before the forfeit, Middletown had recorded their first undefeated season since 1965.

They previously experienced eligibility issues in 2019, when they had to forfeit three divisional games and four games total en route to missing the playoffs.

Read original at New York Post

The Perspectives

0 verified voices · Three viewpoints · Real discourse

Left
0
Be the first to share a left perspective
Center
0
Be the first to share a center perspective
Right
0
Be the first to share a right perspective

Related Stories