Make New York Post a Preferred Source Tarnished reputation.
An Ohio woman has inspired the ire of the masses after revealing that a jeweler added a 35 percent ‘mandatory tip’ to her bill without her knowledge or consent.
Nelly Venegas, who posted the saga on TikTok earlier this month, said that after she hired a jeweler to come to her home and outfit her and six friends with permanent jewelry, the not-so-sterling service provider added a shocking tip to the final invoice.
“I recently had someone who provided a service for me give themselves a $350 tip without going over that with me or telling me in advance that it was going to happen,” Venegas said.
Venegas found the permanent jewelry company through Facebook ahead of a party she was planning.
In advance, Venegas was told each piece of jewelry cost $100, a price she says she was happy to pay.
“There was never any contract or anything like that, nor was it disclosed or mentioned that there was any sort of travel or set-up fee,” Venegas maintains.
As agreed, a woman, who Venegas did not name, came to her home and positioned the jewelry on seven women.
“At the end of the night, when she was leaving, I gave her the credit card to run,” said Venegas.
“I did not ask ‘What is the total?’ because in my head, I knew what it should have been.”
Her ballpark estimate was $700 for the seven bracelets, plus $200 for extra charms/jewelry connectors and tax.
However, when she reviewed the bill days later, she saw that she had been charged for eight bracelets and a $350 gratuity fee.
“I was definitely confused when I got the receipt. Me and my husband were feeling a little bit scammed. There was no discussion of a travel fee, no mention of a mandatory service fee or a tip,” she explained in the video.
Venegas clarified that she believes the woman deserved a tip, maintaining that she would have gladly added one if she had been asked.
“When she took my card, she did not say, ‘Would you like to leave a tip?’ Had she said that, I would have been like, ‘absolutely.’ I would have left what would have been a reasonable tip for the whole party,” she said.
Venegas did not specify what she considers a reasonable tip.
She added that she believed the woman’s time and services were covered in the price of the product she provided.
When Venegas called the business to contest the charges, she was refunded the $100 charge for the extra bracelet but was told the $350 tip was mandatory.
She signed off, asking viewers for advice and underscoring that she was “not trying to bash” the woman, who, by her own account, “did a wonderful job.”
Venegas also took accountability for her role in the conundrum.
“I should have asked at the end of the night what the total was,” she admitted.
“But I do still feel like it’s not OK to give yourself such a large tip on someone’s card without that being in a contract or without mentioning it before.”
“Do I fight it? Do I let it go?” she asked her audience.
“Tipping yourself over 20 percent without consent is wild behavior and fraud if you ask me,” said one commenter.
“Fight it, or she will keep doing it to other people,” said another.
“She is scamming people; do not let it go,” urged a third.
A permanent jewelry artist also added her opinion to the chorus, writing, “Never ever would I expect a tip… let alone charge a tip to someone’s card without them personally writing in a tip of their own accord. The whole thing is weird… I’d fight it… she’s being shady,” they wrote.
The video inspired two follow-up posts. In the third installment, Venegas shared that she was ultimately refunded for the tip and received an apology email from the company’s owners.
The owners maintained they were unaware of the charge and even lauded Venegas for calling attention to it.
“We acknowledge that the $350 tip was processed without your prior approval or signature, and we sincerely apologize for that mistake. A full refund of the $350 tip has already been issued to the original payment method,” stated the email that Venegas read aloud.
“We also want to make it clear, as owners, we were unaware of this charge and have never had a policy requiring a travel fee or mandatory gratuity for off-site events. We are grateful you brought this to our attention, as it has allowed us to address a situation that does not reflect our business practices or standards.”
Commenters applauded Venegas’ handling of the situation, particularly her decision not to reveal the business’s name.
“As a small business owner, I appreciate you allowing the business to make it right before naming and shaming them,” said one commenter.
“My goal was NEVER to ruin a small business,” Venegas emphasized.
The spicy comments section reflects growing discontent among Americans who increasingly feel “harassed and extorted” by hidden costs and surprise surcharges being tacked onto already-inflated bills.