Video Immigration expert Steven Camarota discusses concerns over amnesty Steven Camarota of the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) discouraged an amnesty deal as President Donald Trump considers working with Democrats on immigration.
After President Donald Trump signaled in a "60 Minutes" interview that aired shortly after the midterm elections that he was willing to "work on a deal" with Democrats to allow some illegal immigrants to gain legal status, Fox News Digital spoke with several immigration experts about the potential ramifications of such an agreement.
The interview came just days after Republicans suffered crushing losses in the midterm elections, raising questions about whether Trump might be willing to compromise on immigration. But the president later ruled out amnesty, saying, "There won't be amnesty," while maintaining that his immigration policy had not changed.
While Trump has not outlined a specific proposal, his comments have raised questions about what a potential deal could look like and how granting legal status to some illegal immigrants could impact the rule of law, assimilation and fiscal policy.
TRUMP ADMITS IMMIGRATION ENFORCEMENT MAY HAVE BEEN TOO 'TOUGH' IN FIRST INTERVIEW SINCE MIDTERMS
President Donald Trump signed two executive orders on Sept. 19, 2025, establishing the "Trump Gold Card" and introducing a $100,000 fee for H-1B visas. The "Trump Gold Card" is a visa program that allows foreign nationals permanent residency and a pathway to U.S. citizenship for a $1 million investment in the United States. (Andrew Harnik/Getty Images)
Fox News Digital spoke with three immigration experts about what a potential agreement could mean for the country, including its impact on the rule of law, assimilation and taxpayers.
"I think one of the first things we have to always consider is the impact on the rule of law and does it undermine it. It's very hard to argue that the best way to restore the rule of law and deal with illegal immigration is to reward some large fraction of people who've broken the law," said Steven Camarota, the director of research at the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS).
Camarota believes that amnesty begs the question of basic fairness, and impacts how people who have come to the United States legally view the immigration system.
He used the example of a person who illegally overstays a visa to illustrate his point, saying that person shouldn't be rewarded with citizenship after overstaying a visa, especially when there are millions of people who have already followed the law and left the country when their visas expired.
Laura Collins, director of immigration policy at the George W. Bush Presidential Center, acknowledged those concerns but argued that the country's immigration laws are part of the problem.
AMERICA NEEDS WORKERS, BUT TRUMP'S POLICIES ARE SHARPLY CUTTING LEGAL IMMIGRATION
"I understand people's concerns about the rule of law," said Collins. "I also think you have a set of immigration laws that are not working as intended. The reason we have so many people who are here undocumented is because we have an economy that pulls in a lot of people's work, but an immigration system that restricts that labor flow."
Immigrants take the oath of citizenship to the United States during a naturalization ceremony at Liberty State Park on Sept. 19, 2014, in Jersey City, New Jersey. (John Moore/Getty Images)
She says the United States is at a crossroads: the country can choose a system where illegal immigrants cannot stay and fix their mistakes while also contributing to the economy, or they can stay and be offered a chance at restitution.
"Almost every single piece of legislation that has had a chance at passage on immigration that involves legalization program has had things like paying back taxes, going through a background check, paying some sort of fine or fee or restitution payment in order to make up for the fact that these people did something illegal by either overstaying a visa or crossing the border," she said.
But Camarota questioned whether a future amnesty agreement would actually require immigrants to complete those restitution payments before obtaining citizenship.
Camarota also said that one of the main reasons for restricting immigration in the first place is to ensure that the United States isn't overwhelmed.
"We don't want the numbers to be so large that they overwhelm the assimilation process, where you can go to a school where everyone's from your background or you don't ever have to learn English, because there's enough people around you who you don't [and] who you speak your native tongue So that's one reason to limit immigration," he said.
President Donald Trump takes questions as he announced the creation of the "Trump-class" battleship during a statement to the media at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago estate on December 22, 2025, in Palm Beach, Florida. (Photo by Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images)
"In effect, an amnesty throws that out the window and says, well, we have these limits, but we're not going to enforce them," he continued.
TRUMP SAYS DEPORTATION PUSH HASN’T PUT 'SAME PRESSURE' ON FARMWORKERS, HOTEL STAFF: 'NOT EVEN CLOSE'
Drawing from the findings of a 2022 book called "Streets of Gold: America's Untold Story of Immigrant Success," Collins argued that today's immigrants are assimilating at a pace similar to that of immigrants of prior generations. America's current foreign-born population has matched a historic peak similar to late 1800s and early 1900s levels. About 15% of the current population is foreign-born.
The book, she said, compared people's memories of how their grandparents and great-grandparents assimilated when they came to the United States.
"And what they found was actually that immigrants are integrating it pretty much the same rates," she said.
She also said that work helps people to assimilate faster, and thus, if illegal immigrants were given the opportunity to work legally, assimilation would be a smoother process.
"I do think that one of the things America really is good at is us taking newcomers and turning them into Americans, and so I worry less about that" she said. "But I understand why there is a scenario where people could be afraid of that. But the data doesn't support it."
Camarota estimated that households headed by illegal immigrants receive approximately $50 billion annually in government benefits, often through programs for which their U.S.-born children are eligible. He cited Medicaid, Supplemental Security Income (SSI), Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF) and free school lunches as examples, although illegal immigrants themselves are generally barred from receiving many federal welfare benefits.
TRUMP TELLS DHS CHIEF TO WORK WITH DEMOCRATS ON IMMIGRATION REFORM, BUT NO AMNESTY
Illegal immigrants use welfare not because they're lazy, but because most of them do not have educations higher than 11th grade level, Camarota said.
"Legalizing folks doesn't change the fact that the illegal population is overwhelmingly less educated, and less educated people just don't pay enough in taxes to cover their consumption of public services, especially when you consider all the means-tested programs they get," he said.
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents conduct immigration enforcement operations in Minneapolis on Jan. 28, 2026. (Madison Thorn/Anadolu via Getty Images)
Low-income people, he noted, simply don't pay much in taxes.
"Remember, half of all workers pay no federal income tax," he said. "So, yes, illegal immigrants do pay taxes, and actually we think more than half already work on the books, so there's no big boon to taxpayers anyway. But now, they themselves will become eligible for welfare programs."
Collins conceded that while many immigrants have low education levels, he said that that doesn't mean all of them are working jobs that meet their education skills. She pointed to a 2013 Congressional Budget Office (CBO) analysis of the Gang of Eight's immigration bill, S. 744, which estimated that the legislation would increase federal tax revenues and reduce federal deficits by approximately $158 billion over 10 years, despite increased spending on government benefits.
"You get a little bit more tax revenue," she said. "They are potentially making higher wages, they're able to negotiate for different jobs and different wages because they have that legal work authorization," Collins said.
HISPANIC VOTERS ARE NATURAL CONSERVATIVES. REAGAN KNEW. GOP NEEDS TO PROVE IT AGAIN
She argued that with legal work authorization, some illegal immigrants would be able to fulfill their full potential in higher-level jobs.
Mark Krikorian runs CIS. He said that while thinking through the pros and cons of amnesty might be a useful thought exercise, the point is probably moot.
People wait inside a U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services office. The Trump administration issued a new rule allowing USCIS to refer certain asylum applications directly to immigration judges without first conducting an affirmative asylum interview. (John Moore/Getty Images)
"Well, to begin with, it's not going to happen," he said of an amnesty deal. The likelihood of anything happening, certainly until the Democrats come in, until the next Congress comes in, and even then, it is, in my opinion, close to zero."
For two reasons, Krikorian doesn't think Republicans have leverage to make a deal.
He says Democrats won't be willing to concede any restrictions on immigration, thus leaving Republicans with no incentive to make an amnesty deal for illegal immigrants.
HOUSE REPUBLICANS MOVE TO MAKE TRUMP'S BORDER POLICIES PERMANENT
He used DACA as an example. Recently, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin floated the possibility of a compromise involving DACA recipients — people who came to the United States as children and received temporary protections from deportation — that could give them permanent legal status.
"A DACA amnesty? Frankly, the DACAs already have amnesty. It's upgrading them from amnesty light to amnesty premium," he said.
He said the first Trump administration tried making a deal for tighter immigration measures using DACA recipients as a bargaining chip.
Pro-DACA protestors hold a march outside the U.S. Capitol Building calling for a pathway to citizenship on November 17, 2022, in Washington, D.C. (Nathan Posner/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images)
"That idea is valuable and could be productive, but there's no way that upgrading the DACA who already have Social Security numbers and work permits to regular green card status is something that the Democrats would give anything in exchange for," he said.
But Krikorian warned that giving green cards to DACA recipients could eventually allow them to sponsor additional relatives, including their parents, once they become U.S. citizens, although existing immigration restrictions could prevent some relatives from obtaining legal status.
"And that would have some effects, because once you have a green card, you can petition for certain relatives, and the five-year clock for citizenship starts," he said. "And when you become a citizen, you could then petition for your parents. There's no numerical caps for that."
Trump discussed on "60 Minutes" potentially working out a deal that would allow some illegal immigrants working in industries like hospitality and landscaping to remain in the country.
"When you go into a hotel, and you have a woman that's working there as a maid, as a cleaner as a this, as a that, as a waitress, a lot of good things, great jobs, and all of a sudden they're being taken out of the country, it's tough. It's a tough thing," Trump said on "60 Minutes."
Federal agents patrol the halls of immigration court at the Jacob K. Javitz Federal Building on July 8, 2025, in New York City. Various council members and a state senator attended immigration hearings and observed Immigration and Customs Enforcement as they continued their stepped-up tactics of detaining people during routine check-ins or showing up to court for their immigration hearings. (Spencer Platt/Getty Images)
MULLIN VOWS ‘ZERO CHANGE’ ON IMMIGRATION AFTER REPUBLICANS SUFFER CRUSHING MIDTERM LOSSES
He added that people whom he described as "far-right" want deportations regardless of whether the illegal immigrant is working.
The White House, meanwhile, says Trump's "strong immigration policy remains unchanged," and White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis told Fox News Digital that Democrats should work with the president to keep the border secure, remove dangerous criminal illegal immigrants from the country and stop drug trafficking.
She said the president's "commonsense immigration agenda" has resulted in the "most secure border in history."
SIGN UP TO GET THE POLITICS NEWSLETTER
"If Democrats choose to pursue radical left open border and mass amnesty policies, they are choosing to work against the interests of the American people," she said.
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP
The Department of Homeland Security did not return a request for comment.
Peter D'Abrosca is a politics reporter at Fox News Digital.