California is pulling the plug on the wildly recognizable Kars4Kids jingle after an Orange County judge ruled the charity’s ads misled donors about who actually benefits from their money.
Orange County Superior Court Judge Gassia Apkarian found that the organization violated California false advertising and unfair competition laws by failing to disclose that donations primarily fund Orthodox Jewish programs tied to Oorah Inc., a New York and New Jersey-based outreach organization.
The ruling was published May 8 and comes after California resident Bruce Puterbaugh sued the charity in 2021, claiming he donated his car after repeatedly hearing the famous ad and believed the proceeds would help underprivileged children in California.
Instead, Puterbaugh learned the $250 generated from his donated vehicle went to programs connected to Oorah, which focuses on Jewish heritage camps and religious outreach.
According to the ruling, Kars4Kids Chief Operating Officer Esti Landau testified that the charity’s “primary function” is funding Oorah’s programs.
Landau also testified that although about 25% of Kars4Kids’ revenue comes from California, the organization has virtually no meaningful programs benefiting children in the state beyond a backpack drive described in court as a “branding exercise.”
The court further heard that Kars4Kids funding was not primarily directed toward young children in need.
Instead, money supported older teens, including 17- and 18-year-olds participating in gap-year trips to Israel and related family programming.
Testimony also revealed that $16.5 million was spent in 2022 on a building purchase in Israel, while another $437,000 went toward “Middle East outreach.”
Judge Apkarian ruled the commercials were “misleading by omission” because they failed to disclose the organization’s religious affiliation, where the money was spent, and the actual age range of beneficiaries.
“The public interest is served by transparency in the ‘charity marketplace,’” the order states.
“When a charity generates millions annually through a ‘jingle’ that conceals its primary religious and geographic focus, it creates an unfair playing field for local California charities that are honest about their missions.”
Under the ruling, Kars4Kids can no longer air its commercials in California unless the ads include “an express, audible disclosure” explaining the charity’s religious affiliation, where donations go and who benefits from the funds.
The organization is also barred from using young children in its ads.
The court gave Kars4Kids 30 days to remove noncompliant commercials from California airwaves, meaning the catchy tune may still linger briefly on radio and TV.
Kars4Kids, a registered 501(c)(3) nonprofit based in Lakewood, New Jersey, operates a car donation program that funds educational and recreational programs for Jewish children and families, primarily through Oorah.The charity has faced scrutiny before. Pennsylvania and Oregon fined Kars4Kids in 2009 for “misleading solicitation practices,” and a 2017 Minnesota attorney general investigation found that less than 1% of the $3 million donated in the state benefited local children.
