New York Post Composite Did you know that some of the best Amazon mattresses are name brand? It’s true, and they’re typically less than what you’ll find at other retailers.
While we at the Post are not newbies when it comes to sleep products, when mattresses are concerned, it doesn’t hurt to get some expert advice in picking one.
“A good mattress will keep your spine aligned while you sleep,” Shelby Harris, PsyD, licensed clinical psychologist and director of sleep health at Sleepopolis, told the New York Post.
“Your sleep position, body type, and personal preferences for feel and materials will all play a role in determining which mattress is best suited for your needs.”
Peruse our in-depth FAQ section, where we help answer the questions you stay up at night thinking about (probably on your meh mattress, which is why you’re reading this), like what to look for, depending on your usual sleep position, and much, much more.
Below, Dr. Harris hand-picks the best Amazon mattresses you can snag right now (we’ve added some of our favorites, too).
According to Harris, this mattress is best for side sleepers or anyone who enjoys a softer memory foam mattress.
“It uses six inches of memory foam on the top layer that decreases motion transfer, promotes spinal alignment and provides good edge support,” she adds.
Mattress Type: Memory foam | Firmness level: Medium-Firm | Amazon rating: 4.3 | Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
If you’re seeking a luxury mattress that you’ll actually be dreaming about, it’s sure to be the Beautyrest Black Series Three Plush Pillow Top Mattress. By far, it’s one of the most luxurious options we’ve lied down on in store, thanks to its pillow-top comfort that, in our opinion, is the perfect medium of support and softness.
I have tested and reviewed this mattress, and it’s still the greatest item in my home one year later. Its motion separation feature helps reduce what you feel if you’re sleeping with a partner, so I hardly wake up if my husband is tossing and turning.
Giardina’s BeautyRest Mattress. Victoria Giardina According to our experts, pillow top mattresses are excellent options for side sleepers, especially if you’re sharing a bed with a partner. It’s also the brand’s most advanced level of individualized support and motion separation, so you’re in for a treat.
While the price point is higher than some others, you can’t beat its quality or design. Constructed with a premium memory foam layer and infused with diamond particles, it’s designed to help move heat away from the body for a cool sleep. Talk about luxury.
Mattress Type: Hybrid | Firmness level: Pillow Top, Plush | Mattress Size: Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
For an affordable option that is planet-approved, try the Zinus Green Tea Memory Foam Mattress. Its CertiPUR-certified foams are free of formaldehyde and other problematic stuff, while its green tea and charcoal-infused layer keeps moisture away — and the bacteria that follow it. Thousands — and we mean thousands — of Amazon shoppers love it!
Mattress Type: Memory foam | Firmness level: Plush/Soft | Amazon rating: 4.4 | Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King | Available in sizes 5-12 inches
The Casper Original Mattress is made entirely of foam and has a middle layer that stays soft for certain sections of the body and firm for others.
“It also has great pressure relief and support, so it’s a good option for back sleepers or those who have back pain,” Harris notes.
I previously owned a Casper mattress and I loved how swift the bed-in-a-box mattress assembly process was. Unlike hiring someone from a department store to deliver and set up my mattress, Casper took the middleman out and added the convenience in, which I noted in my full Casper review.
I’ve always been on the fence about mattresses that come straight out of a box but let me tell you — it expanded in less than 5 minutes (magic!) and was super easy to place atop my elevating mattress base (or, you can place it atop your boxspring, though I find you don’t need one).
Victoria Giardina Mattress Type: Memory foam | Firmness level: Medium-Firm | Amazon rating: 4.4 | Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
The Purple Mattress has excellent temperature regulation and airflow, making it a good option for hot sleepers.
“The top layer of GelFlex Grid can help reduce pain and relieve pressure, so this is also a good choice for sleepers looking for a mattress to help with pain relief- or combination sleepers who change positions throughout the night,” Harris explains.
Ryan Murphy, former commerce partnerships manager, who wrote a review of the Purple Mattress, also had a lot of positive things to say.
Unboxing has never been so easy! Ryan Murphy “My wife sleeps in every position under the sun (well, moon). I primarily sleep on my side, but no matter the position, the Purple Mattress has given us support where we want it and allows us to sink in where we need it, providing that perfect balance of soft and firm. After a day or two, any aches and pains we used to have from our old mattress disappeared.”
Mattress Type: Memory foam | Firmness level: Medium-Firm | Amazon rating: 4.5 | Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
The Studio by Leesa Mattress uses a combination of memory foam and poly foam to give this mattress great support and pressure relief.
“This mattress also has great motion isolation, so it’s a good option for anyone who sleeps with a partner or a pet,” Harris notes.
Mattress Type: Memory foam | Firmness level: 5-7, relaxed firm | Amazon rating: 4.4 Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Amazon Pros: Individually wrapped coils reduce motion transfer, ideal for couples or families Comes compressed and rolled in a box for easy shipping Cons: May not be firm enough for those who prefer a very firm mattress The BedStory 14-inch Hybrid King Mattress offers a luxurious combination of memory foam and individually wrapped coils, providing balanced pressure relief and support for all types of sleepers. The best Amazon mattress is designed to minimize motion transfer, making it ideal for couples who value uninterrupted sleep.
Shipped conveniently in a box, it takes 72 hours to fully expand after unpacking. Assembled in the USA and CertiPUR-US certified, this medium-firm mattress promises both comfort and durability, offering a high-quality sleep experience tailored to various preferences.
Mattress Type: Hybrid (Memory Foam & Individually Wrapped Coils) | Firmness level: Medium (14 inches) | Amazon rating: 4.9 | Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
According to Harris: “This bed is super soft and has great support for the hips and shoulders.” For this reason, it’s ideal for side sleepers.
Mattress Type: Memory foam | Firmness level: Firm | Amazon rating: 4.5 | Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Experience luxury sleep with the Helix Midnight Luxe Mattress. Designed with a plush Euro top and three layers of premium foam, it offers pressure relief tailored to your needs. The zoned lumbar support keeps your spine aligned, while hundreds of individually wrapped steel coils ensure stability and motion isolation.
Plus, full perimeter edge support means you can stretch out without sagging. Delivered in a box for easy setup, this king-size mattress brings hotel-quality comfort to your home. Choose the perfect firmness for your sleep style and get ready to rest in pure luxury.
Overall, we prefer this mattress to our previous memory foam mattress.
Not only does the reduced temperature help regulate my body heat, making for a more comfortable night’s sleep, but the minimal motion transfer between my wife and I helps us sleep more peacefully now that we don’t feel each other toss and turn so much.
Mattress Type: Hybrid (Coils and Foam) | Firmness level: Medium | Amazon rating: 4.7 Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
“The Tuft & Needle Mattress is an all-foam medium-feel mattress that is very supportive, cooling and great for back sleepers who need to maintain healthy spine alignment throughout the night,” Harris highlights.
The mattress also comes at an affordable price point.
Mattress Type: Memory foam | Firmness level: Medium-Firm | Amazon rating: 4.4 | Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
You probably didn’t know that you could buy Brooklyn Bedding mattresses on Amazon, but you absorb can! The brand is a favorite of sleep editors everywhere, mainly for its pressure-relieving design. The Select 14″ Gel Memory Foam Hybrid Mattress has a quilted top and high-density foam to support your joints as you switch positions. The model also has 8-inch acesion coils for additional support, as well as contouring and enhanced motion isolation. Available at various heights, it comes with a 10-year warranty.
Mattress Type: Memory foam | Firmness level: Medium-Firm | Amazon rating: 4.3 | Mattress Size: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
Ahead, our team of sleep experts answers some of the most frequently asked questions about ordering a mattress on Amazon online, along with what to know depending on specific sleep preferences, whether it be a Sleep Number, Serta, or finding the best foldable mattress for every night sleep on Amazon.
“A good mattress should balance support and comfort, meaning that it keeps your spine in alignment while also preventing any pressure points,” David Rubin, director of product testing at TheSleepDoctor.com, told The Post.
According to Harris, your sleep position, body type, and personal preferences for feel and materials will all play a role in determining which mattress is best suited for your needs. “You also want to consider cost, convenience, durability, whether or not you sleep with a partner and any sleep issues you may regularly face — hot sleepers, back pain, etc. — and shop for mattresses designed as remedies for these specific needs.”
A significant aspect to consider: if you’re frequently changing positions, there is a good chance your sleep is fragmented, leading you to lose out on the deeper stages of sleep. This makes you more likely to wake up tired, even if you thought you got 8 hours of sleep.
“When you’re trying out the mattress, you should be able to lie in one position without moving around for at least a few minutes,” Alanna McGinn, CEO and certified sleep expert at Good Night Sleep Site, told The Post. “If you can do that, you’ve found a good mattress.”
“The mattress is truly the foundation of our good night sleep. Our bed is where we spend (or should spend) one third of our lives, so make sure to take time to find the right mattress that suits you personally. There is no one size fits all when it comes to mattresses. What is important is that the mattress supports you in your desired sleeping position and is appropriate for your personal preference for plush or firm.”
Ahead, our sleep experts list and explain the different types of mattresses you can order online:
According to Rubin, back sleepers “generally need a medium firm mattress with solid support.” This can come from any material, though a hybrid — he shares — is most likely to provide the right balance of support and cushioning with the slimmest margin for error.
“If a mattress is too firm, back sleepers could experience back or shoulder pain due to unnecessary tension throughout the night,” Harris added. “If the mattress is too soft, the spine can’t align correctly and can also cause pain in the morning.”
“It’s important to keep your body aligned when sleeping on your side,” McGinn advised. “You want to take the pressure off your hips and shoulders and will be looking for plush and ultra plush mattress options like a memory foam or pillow top mattress.”
That said, side sleepers should avoid a mattress that’s too soft, according to Ruth, as that can cause the spine to curve and fall out of alignment. (Related: Best pillows for every sleeper).
Stomach sleepers will most likely find a firm or ultra-firm mattress the most comfortable. “A firm mattress will help align the hips with the shoulders while on their stomach,” Harris noted. “A soft mattress may cause the hips to sink out of alignment with the rest of the spine, which can be uncomfortable and lead to pain in the morning.”
Looking for a highly supportive mattress between a seven and nine on the firmness scale is ideal. “Stomach sleepers will likely do best on an innerspring or hybrid mattress,” she added.
“A memory foam mattress can be a great choice for cold sleepers as they lock in the heat,” McGinn shared. Harris adds that these may look like breathable innerspring mattresses, and you’ll want to steer clear of any mattress that boasts added cooling materials.
Interestingly, bedding plays a significant role, according to Rubin. “Flannel sheets, thick blankets and comforters and even weighted blankets can make any mattress feel warmer.” (Related: Best duvet covers).
Innerspring mattresses promote airflow, helping circulate body heat and increase breathability. Latex mattresses are also naturally cooling and won’t trap your body heat, keeping you cool while you sleep. “There are a lot of mattresses that have cooling materials as well, such as copper-infused foams or Phase Change Material,” Harris added.
“This is where you may want to choose an innerspring coil mattress that provides better airflow and a cooler sleep,” said McGinn.
Like any product, It’s important to do your research. But, with mattresses, pay close attention to the construction, foam density (generally, the denser, the better) and any unique technology the mattress may include (Phase Change Material, moisture-wicking properties, etc.), according to Harris.
“Check if the brand offers a trial period in case you need to return your mattress if it doesn’t work for you or arrives defective,” she pointed out. “Keep in mind that every brand is different, and you should always read the fine print regarding warranties and returns before you purchase a new mattress.”
According to Rubin, it takes your body 21 to 30 days for your circadian rhythm to adjust and get used to a new mattress, so make sure your mattress trial period is at least 60 days.
Especially with online mattress shopping growing in popularity, McGinn noted, shuffling through online store reviews can give you the best information you need to make sure that you are choosing the best mattress for your specific sleep needs.
If your mattress starts to sag or has noticeable impressions, it’s probably time to replace it, according to Rubin.
“In general, a mattress should last about six to nine years, depending on the material,” he added. Memory foam will have the shortest lifespan, too.
“Outside of this time frame, if your mattress is uncomfortable, negatively affecting your sleep or is noticeably saggy or damaged in certain areas, it may be time to shop for a replacement,” McGinn recommended.
For over 200 years, the New York Post has been America’s go-to source for bold news, engaging stories, in-depth reporting, and now, insightful shopping guidance. We’re not just thorough reporters – we sift through mountains of information, test and compare products, and consult experts on any topics we aren’t already schooled specialists in to deliver useful, realistic product recommendations based on our extensive and hands-on analysis. Here at The Post, we’re known for being brutally honest – we clearly label partnership content, and whether we receive anything from affiliate links, so you always know where we stand. We routinely update content to reflect current research and expert advice, provide context (and wit) and ensure our links work. Please note that deals can expire, and all prices are subject to change.
Looking for a headline-worthy haul? Keep shopping Post Wanted.
